Wild Pastures vs. Butcher Box: Which One Stands Out?
We have subscriptions for everything; clothes, television, hair products so why not subscribe for essential food items, like your meat as well?
Ordering your meat online and having it delivered to your door might sound like a foreign concept, but sourcing online is actually a great way to ensure you know exactly what you’re getting. Trying to find ethically raised, high-quality meat at your local store can feel like a scavenger hunt, but luckily, there are a number of services that deliver premium meat to your door.
We looked at different meat delivery subscriptions and narrowed the list down to Wild Pastures and Butcher Box. Our editors tried both and here is what they thought:
Key Similarities:
- Both are subscription-based services that are flexible and deliver right to your door.
- Wild Pastures and Butcher Box are both 100% grass-fed beef that are high quality.
- They both have a wide range of plans and box sizes.
Key Differences:
- Wild Pastures meat is all sourced from local US farmers, unlike Butcher Box.
- Wild Pastures is 100% pasture-raised bovine which means that they raised in a natural environment and feed off the land.
- Wild Pastures has a zero-waste policy – they make every effort to optimize the use of the entire animal and distribute the cuts evenly.
Wild Pastures Overview:
Wild Pastures is a premium membership club that delivers 100% grass-fed, pasture-raised meat at affordable prices. The meat is sourced from local U.S farmers, which is a great way to ensure the highest quality of meat while also supporting small local family-run businesses. It is beneficial for the farmers, the economy and the planet.
Wild Pastures’ website is completely transparent about their farming practices. They use a rotational grazing technique that does not include pesticides or harmful chemicals allowing their bovine to have a healthier, happier life. This method doesn’t need external resources and in turn, toxins won’t be passed down to you from the meat.
Their animals are raised in natural habitats and feed off the land, making them 100% pasture-raised. They also have a zero-waste policy, through which they use the entire animal and distribute various cuts evenly between their members.
They have two membership plans – Standard and their most popular Plus plan which gives you free shipping and allows you to save 25-40% on pasture-raised meats. The most popular is the 20-21 lbs (40 – 8 ounce servings) and costs $178.
Butcher Box Overview:
Butcher Box is a meat and seafood delivery subscription. They have 100% grass-fed beef, organic chicken, humanely raised pork, and wild-caught seafood. They also have a wide range of quality cuts from ground beef to filet mignon.
Butcher Box partners with farmers and other third-party suppliers. You can choose from 4 different custom boxes and quantities you would like. They are delivered to your doorstep on your schedule.
Butcher Box has a range of meats but they are not pasture-raised or domestically sourced. The custom box is the most popular of the bunch and includes 9-14 lbs of high-quality meat. It includes free shipping and costs $149 per month.
Final Thoughts:
They are both meat delivery subscriptions that are flexible and allow you to skip, cancel anytime. Both Wild Pastures and Butcher Box are 100% grass-fed beef but Wild Pastures stands out as all their meat is locally sourced from US farmers and 100% pasture-raised.
The price per lb with Wild Pastures is the best value as you get a lot more meat in your box. Our editors have loved Wild Pastures and you cannot beat the quality of the meat you are receiving.
If you are looking for 100% grass-fed beef that is high in quality and locally sourced then Wild Pastures is the one for you.
