I honestly don’t know what this game is.
Asymmetric Production’s West of Loathing is nothing if not unique – it’s world is fresh and vibrant despite the stick figured, black-and-white design. It’s characters manage to be simple, but real enough for you not to care. And it’s story is like the large desert with which it takes place: A huge mystery, just waiting to be solved.
THE GAME
THE GOOD
It would also distract from the game’s astounding branching narrative. It starts simple enough – you want to help a train clear a path so you can make it all the way to Frisco – a beautiful town in the west. That’s all well and good, and you can do it relatively quick if that’s how you want to play. But the more explore this world the more you get to experience game’s gleefully kooky side quests which involve: Hellcows (yes, cows from Hell), necromancers, aliens, and even clowns! Each of these quests has a lot of twists and turns that take you to some strange places throughout the map. You have to solve puzzles, quest for needles in haystacks, and even learn a whole new language.
And it’s never easy – none of these quests are ever easy. The creatures you fight are always balanced fairly well, and you have to think very carefully about what you’re going to do next. The battle-system isn’t the best, but it works well enough to make the game challenging in a fun way most of the time.
Aside from story elements, the game also manages to throw some of their own beans in the RPG soup – in the place of typical classes, you get Cow Puncher (Muscle), Beanslinger (Mysticality [magic]), and Snake Oiler (Moxie [speech/bartering]). Each affect how you’ll move through the story: For instance, if you pick Beanslinger – you’ll be able to use your bean magic to influence the random encounters you could get, while as a Snake Oiler you’d be able to negotiate with a trader to get some good loot! The classes all seem familiar, but the devs manage to make their lore and application in the world feel totally fresh.
There’s a lot that makes this game great – it’s differences mostly work for this game, not against it. However, like all games, this one is far from perfect.
THE BAD
First, there’s the battle system. The tactical turnbased doesn’t work super well, mostly because it just gets old. Even as you get more and more abilities, the battles become more tedious than fun – it takes a while but it can happen. Difficulty isn’t the problem – as I’ve said, the difficulty mostly works – but its problem lies with the sameness. In a world that has something new around every corner, I expect the battle system to do the same.
Another problem lies within the game’s sometimes punishing nature. For example, I was in a large bull-bone tower (you’ll have to play to really experience what I’m talking about), and I missed one thing and shut it off for the rest of the game. There’s no way for me to fix it, and that kind of thing really bothers me – especially since the whole game relies on exploration. It’d be fine if there was a way for me to reload my save – but you can’t do that, not in West of Loathing.
It ruins a bit of the experience for me, even though I appreciate the dev’s focus on the consequences of choice.
THE BOTTOM LINE
West of Loathing is an odd, hilarious sight to behold. From the Lovecraftian aliens, hellish demon cows, and reanimated skeletons to the beanmagic and cactus-loving goblins – this world brims with strange, energetic life. Sure, the battle system leaves much to be desired and the lack of load-able save files can throw you for a loop, but that doesn’t distract from this incredibly fun title.
And it’s only $10.99 on Steam!
Shann Smith is a lover of video games and has played games since he could hold a controller. He is a freelance writer, playwright, screenwriter, and also writes the Video Gay-Mer column on Popdust! If you have any games you’d like him to unpack, hit him up!
POP⚡ DUST | Read More ROLE PLAYGROUND…
ROLE PLAYGROUND | Hellblade’s thrilling ride through the psyche
ROLE PLAYGROUND | Does ‘Finding Paradise’ live up to its predecessor ‘To The Moon’?
ROLE PLAYGROUND | The Intimate Uniqueness of To the Moon…
ROLE PLAYGROUND | Why is Final Fantasy XII so Misunderstood?
