Ahh, memories. It feels like only yesterday, we were seeing endless images of Justin Bieber and Selena Gomez out together, young and in love and ever so photogenic. But yesterday is gone with the wind, and now Bieber and Gomez are officially pop music’s most eligible bachelor and bachelorette under U.S. drinking age. Before we permanently close the book on the power couple, let’s take one final look back on the moments that have defined their relationship—at least for us creepy onlookers—over the last few years. (Make sure there’s a box of tissues nearby, though. You never know.)