Nicki Minaj Finally Admits It: American Idol Is “Not a Singing Competition”
Posted by Newson 02/14/2013 at 9:56 AM
One of the most pernicious myths about pop music is that singers with great voices are somehow more “real” than ones whose voices are merely very good. Certainly, vocals do count to some extent—but pop is not opera. It’s about more than an impressive set of pipes. It’s about operating in a world of, as Nitsuh Abebe puts it, symbols and gestures: Making an image, embodying a narrative, taking audiences on a journey.
But for some reason, it feels cheap to admit this, and doubly cheap to admit it in the context of a televised singing competition, which relies heavily on selling the “All you need is a voice and a dream” angle. Which is why it was so refreshing to see Nicki Minaj of American Idol gleefully destroy the notion of a vocal meritocracy on Twitter last night:
No, this is NOT a “singing competition”. If that were the case, we’d judge w/blindfolds on. Presence, Look, Relatability, Authentic, etc.
— Nicki Minaj (@NICKIMINAJ) February 14, 2013
(And she threw in some subtle shade at The Voice while she was at it!)
Only a few weeks in, Nicki’s already proven herself one of the best Idol judges since Simon, and her willingness to speak happily upend Idol talking points is one of the biggest reasons why.
Check Us Out On
Login to receive the latest pop music news and exclusive offers from Popdust!
We give the Robots' latest opus a song-by-song breakdown, separating the filler from the future dancefloor classics.
An interstellar transmission appropriately closes out Daft Punk's fourth LP.
An unexpectedly awesome collaboration with psychedelic rock hero Panda Bear provides an album highlight.
Steely Dan meets Phoenix on this uncharacteristic Todd Edwards collaboration.
A cinematic end to the second act of "Random Access Memories."
Lil' Biggie is cute in a biggie way.
A sweeping intro and a familiar bass line, but not much else to this "Random Access Memories" ballad.
The Daft Punk and Pharrell song you already know and love.
Beyonce still wants you to worship her, but she's more polite about it this time.
You have to hear this one to believe it.
The first of Pharrell's two sublime guest appearances on "Random Access Memories."
Julian Casbalancas of the Strokes makes a guest appearance that would've been inconceivable a decade ago.
The Robots get deep with the crooning on this "Random Access Memories" ballad.
One of Daft Punk's biggest influences stops by to tell his life story on this "Random Access Memories" track.
"The Game of Love" slows things down for some quality robo-baby-making music.